Bermuda was hammered by two tropical cyclones in less than a week, Fay and Gonzalo. But hitting Bermuda was one of the few things the storms had in common.
Fay was a “messy” storm: gusty, broad, asymmetric, and not well forecast. Although official NHC sustained winds were 75mph in Bermuda (just below hurricane status)—it later briefly reached Category 1 (the least severe hurricane), and gusts were measured of at least 120mph. Fay was also a rapid intensifier. A weak subtropical depression on October 10, which was initially forecast to fizzle, Fay was nearly a hurricane by the time it hit Bermuda late October 11.
Contrast that with Gonzalo. Gonzalo formed the same day Fay struck Bermuda, and in a similar region - northeast of the Leeward Islands. But it was a tight, symmetric, and well-forecast storm. The NHC predicted a near-Bermuda pass for much of Gonzalo’s seven-day track to Bermuda. The NHC’s intensity forecast was good, too, predicting its major hurricane status and subsequent gradual weakening. Gonzalo peaked at Category 4, with 145mph sustained winds, gradually weakening to 110mph by the time it reached Bermuda. (As a consequence of the weakening, Gonzalo did not surpass Hurricane Fabian in the Bermuda record books.)
Two differences between Fay and Gonzalo stand out. Firstly, for Fay, the duration from formation to Bermuda impact was less than two days, while Gonzalo’s duration was about 7 days. Secondly, Fay was a broad, gusty, asymmetric storm, whose rapid intensification was poorly forecast, while Gonzalo was a tight, symmetric tropical storm whose intensification to major hurricane was well forecast. That the officially “weaker” Fay did comparable damage to Bermuda may well be a testament to the power of the unexpected.
Dr Hall is a climate scientist at the NASA Goddard Institute for Space Studies in New York City. He specialises in hurricanes and their relationship to climate. He develops statistical hurricane and weather hazard models, and has worked as a consultant to RMS and reinsurance companies. Dr. Hall can be reached at LinkedIn.
Posted: Monday, October 20th, 2014